It’s raining women

It’s raining women

Rigoletto at the Canadian Opera Company. Conductor Johannes Debus, director Christopher Alden. Among the opening night cast on September 29, 2011: Rigoletto – Quinn Kelsey, Gilda – Ekaterina Sadovnikova, The Duke – Dmitri Pittas. Complete cast & creative, dates, tickets here.

This is an exciting new production that adds new meanings to Rigoletto and makes it serious and entertaining again.

Alden and the set and costume designer Michael Levine place the opera in Verdi’s time, within a recognizably Victorian all-male club to which women gain access only as either servants or playtoys. It’s not a realist set, however, but has many slippages into the dreamy and the uncanny. The perspective of the room is skewed, and at certain moments the lighting is such that it appears that we’re looking at a photograph with some parts blurred out of focus (Duane Schuler is the lighting designer). A lot is also achieved with the gauze curtain – a sort of a transparent veil which sometimes gives patina to the set behind it and at other times singles out the singers in the proscenium for special attention.

In the early homosocial first scenes of Act 1, with the notable men joshing amongst themselves, a deranged woman in a torn dress wanders around the club – the ghost of the “fallen” Monterone daughter who will pop out in some later scenes as well. The door to the club opens and a row of other women dressed up to the Victorian nines comes in marching and fanning themselves robotically. They take their seats to form the ‘public opinion’ of sorts – a similar, mostly silent but observing crowd plays an important part in some of the later scenes, and clap slowly and robotically after the Duke has had his “La donna è mobile” self-congratulation. They remain immobile but voice the gusts of wind in the storm scene.

There are no significant changes in the set in the course of the opera, just significant rearrangements, so when Rigoletto goes home he is effectively only in the far corner of the Duke’s patriarchal domain. The difference is the Angel of the House: the large portrait of Rigoletto’s dead wife who was of course a spotless rose and who observes the action (and Gilda’s propriety) both from the easel and from high above. After Gilda “falls”, the scene opens to the sight of the portrait slashed and vandalized, and Gilda lying at its foot. (The scene of the stealing of Gilda is superbly stylized, but the ladder, leading dangerously high up to the Victorian ceiling, is still central and gets you worried if the singer will fall off.)

The first meeting between Rigoletto and Sparafucile at Rigoletto’s door is nicely rewritten: Rigoletto is sitting just above the orchestra pit, where he often solitarily dwells, and Sparafucile (Philip Ens, very good in the role) sort of emerges from the dark depth of the room, sitting on the table in the company of Maddalena (Kendall Gladen). He brings to mind Chéreau’s Loge from the Reingold, but also the Victorian snake oil salesman and circus master types.

The character of Giovanna (mezzo Megan Latham), originally employed by Rigoletto as Gilda’s carer, is made into a much more important character here. She is in fact the Duke’s domestic and sexual servant. The governess is also the one who disrobes the women who are about to fall prey to the Duke – while Gilda is singing “Caro nome”, the governess all business-like unzips and undresses the young woman, waiting patiently for her to finish the phrase so she can step out of the crinoline. She does the same with Maddalena later in the opera, with the “Don’t think you’re the first, or will be the last” attitude. The storm scene, scary in its wacky Goth Victoriana excess and the lynching of the count Monterone, culminates with the storm lightning spotlight on the governess hiding behind the sofa, bursting into hysterical cackle.

All of this makes perfect sense, and the production ticks away flawlessly according to the rules of its own universe.

Singing was good across the principal roles. Baritone Quinn Kelsey in the title role was a force of nature, with singing reliable at every turn, even though the acting could have been less one-tone. Tenor Dmitri Pittas as the Duke struck the right tone for the character, keeping him safely this side of the caricature and reasserting his youthful charms and bright tenor colours even in somewhat unfavourable circumstance (in one solo aria he’s playing with a pillow between his knees, and in another he’s playing and jumping around with an antique sword). But if Alden wanted to destroy the Duke with mockery, he would have; he actually lets the character pass almost unscathed, and Pittas made the most of the opportunity.

Soprano Ekaterina Sadovnikova has the charisma and the voice for the role (as her “Caro Nome”s on YT can attest) but was insecure in the highest regions of the role on the opening night, which let’s attribute to the nerves.

With the competent (as usual) conducting by Johannes Debus and the COC orchestra playing in near-perfect synch with the tightly choreographed goings-on on the stage, this was a memorable opening night performance.

All photos by Michael Cooper.

Top: Ekaterina Sadovnikova as Gilda and Quinn Kelsey as Rigoletto.

Second: Ekaterina Sadovnikova (centre) as Gilda.

Bottom: A scene featuring (left to right) Dimitri Pittas as the Duke of Mantua, Megan Latham as Giovanna (kneeling), Kendall Gladen as Maddalena, and Phillip Ens as Sparafucile.


9 thoughts on “It’s raining women

  1. My sister calls this opera “Dame in a Bag”. Which is dismissive, but not particularly inaccurate. Anyway this production sounds way cool, and nice interview, btw.

    But ugh, singers on ladders. I’ve seen that go badly, so yes, that would be distracting.

  2. and you get to sit in your usual up close spot? i jealous! sounds like a very nice setting and very good cast. i saw rigoletto twice, and as strange as it may sound, i preferred the one in LA with Sara Coburn and sitting a mile away than the one in Vienna standing much closer with the cast of Patrizia Ciofi, Ramon Vargas, and Dmitri Hvorostovsky! it has a lot to do with the orchestra, and in the vienna case, darn orchestra drowned out everybody! was the orchestra as lovely as when i was visiting? (lovvve the sound and the view from row O 🙂 )

      1. i thought he was great, the only one to make it past the orchestra. Zerbinetta thought he was too handsome for the role (she wrote a report about it, same time last year during Alcina run at wiener staatsoper.) Clothes, hmm, my renaissance history is not that great, was the sort of clothes with some fluffy thingy around the neck 🙂 . there was also peter jelosits (now a bass baritone) in the cast.

  3. I saw the last performance of this Rigoletto and Pittas was not in good form. This is such an unusual production (I have seen 3 different Rigoletto’s recently, including the wonderful Mantua Rigoletto on DVD), but I absolutely loved it. Some brilliant scene ideas that gives new perspectives to this production, and such a wonderful Rigoletto and Gilda. How lucky were are now to get such great casts and production.

  4. Welcome, Karin! Have a cocktail.

    Absolutely, it’s a staging that makes you think.

    Also, it was a bold move on the part of Alexander Neef to cast mostly young, unknown singers in all the roles (apart from Sadovnikova, who has an international career, but is still at the beginning in many ways). Have you caught the Star piece recently about the young cast? Neef said he thought the opera was such a well-known work that you could afford such a major opening of the gates. What he wisely and coyly didn’t talk about was how unusual the production was. I think the official marketing line at the COC was that the production shows the work “as Verdi intended it” or some such neutral statement. A good move.

    Yet the long-toothed critics in the main dailies still complained about the lack of renaissance clothing. What can you do. Uptakes can be reaaaallly slow sometimes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.